Say what
you will about Cleveland and the surrounding rust-belt cities, but we do have
some awfully cool architecture. Old
churches, graveyards, warehouses and parks make for a lot of fun exploration!
![]() |
| Monroe St. Cemetery Entry Arch |
One of my
favorite little gems is Monroe Street Cemetery - found on the near west side of
Cleveland on the edge of Ohio City.
It really
is like something straight out of a movie, and its strong, gothic overtones and
foreboding structures, surrounded by some very, very old headstones, is
something everyone should see in person.
But its history is equally as fascinating.
This plot
of land began officially as six acres in 1836, when Brooklyn Township purchased
it from Richard Lord and his brother-in-law Josiah Barber, who are widely
regarded as the founders of Ohio City. Records show however, that burials took
place on this land as early as 1818, and tombstones dated as early as 1824 can
still be seen today. Currently, the cemetery encompasses over 16.5 acres, is a
Historic Landmark designated by the City of Cleveland Landmarks Commission, and
over 31,000 persons are buried there.
What would
an old historic cemetery be without some famous residents?
There are
more than 500 persons in the cemetery who served in the armed forces and saw
duty during the American Revolution, the War of 1812, the Mexican-American War,
the Civil War, the Spanish-American War and both World Wars, in addition to
those who served their country during times of peace.
There are
many people here who belonged to the Free & Accepted Masons of Ohio, the
Woodmen of the World and the Independent Order of Odd Fellows.
The
cemetery contains several persons who were actively involved in abolitionist
activities before and during the Civil War, including Rev. James A. Thome and
Alfred Greenbrier.
| Rev. James Thome |
Two mayors
of Cleveland are buried here, William Castle and Irvine U. Masters.
| William Castle |
![]() |
| Irvine Masters Marker |
John
Michael Kick, the first Cleveland police officer to be killed in the line of
duty is buried here - in June 2011, Kick was honored with a new marker, and his 2nd great grandson, a police officer in the 5th district, spoke at the event.
| John Michael Kick |
Notable
businessmen from many walks of life are reflected in the multitude of monuments
in the cemetery, including Daniel Sanford, Robert Sanderson, and Gustave
Schaefer.
One of the
early pioneers of the west side and major landowner/developer, Richard Lord, is
interred in what appears to be one of the smallest mausoleums around. So small,
in fact, that his name above the door had to be abbreviated. His wife is also buried in the crypt below -
but a third casket has not been identified.
| Richard Lord's tomb |
Walter M.
Prentice was a physician and Army Surgeon during the Civil War. Recognized as a
surgeon of "rare ability", he died in 1864, while serving as
commandant in the Medical Corps, at Pt Burnside Tennessee.
![]() |
| William Prentice Marker |
Ships'
captains, ships' carpenters, and sailors tell the story of a predominant mode
of transportation in 19th century Cleveland.
Farmers,
bricklayers, shoemakers, factory workers, saloonkeepers, ministers, soapmakers,
livery stable owners, doctors, canal builders and many other trades and skills
were the occupations of the common people resting here who made Ohio City and
Cleveland great.
This
picture of the gatehouse in 2008 shows its sad and dire need for restoration:
| Gatehouse in 2008 |
However, there
is some very good news! This wonderful
structure is under complete renovation - it appears it may be completed this
year. Be sure to follow
http://www.mscf1841.org/ to witness the progress. You can donate there, find great little store
items, and become a member of the cemetery's foundation.
Which
brings me to my NE Ohio genealogical find of the day! The wonderful caretakers and volunteers of
this incredible historical gem will actually take a picture of your relative's
grave if you ask. I recommend making a donation or joining the foundation; but
they have generously offered their services - click here for more information. I've never heard of a cemetery doing this - (three cheers from family researchers everywhere!)
You may
not have an ancestor here, nor may you ever do work for someone who does - but
I cannot recommend enough the support of this local treasure.
Happy
hunting!
Cate.
Note: many
thanks to the following for much of the information contained here:
1. Alan
Fodor, “Monroe Street Cemetery,” Cleveland Historical, accessed January 16,
2014, http://clevelandhistorical.org/items/show/476.
2.
http://www.mscf1841.org/
3.
http://www.findagrave.com





This is fantastic! And good for you, for sharing it here. You may or may not know I'm a big fan of fraternal societies... any other info on those burials you mentioned from the Masons, IOOF, etc? Pictures? Would love to see that. Thanks for posting this one!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Jen :) Means a lot coming from you. I don't have any pictures/info on those fraternal society burials/graves/markers at the moment - but I would be happy to try to make that happen this year. I enjoy learning about them too. I'll let you know when I have the info!
ReplyDeleteCate.
Cate,
ReplyDeleteI want to let you know that your blog post is listed in today's Fab Finds post at http://janasgenealogyandfamilyhistory.blogspot.com/2014/01/follow-friday-fab-finds-for-january-17.html
Have a great weekend!
Thanks, Jana! I appreciate you including me so very much :)
ReplyDelete- Cate.
Love the architecture in Cleveland, especially in the cemeteries.
ReplyDelete